Phone Phone
Section 85 vs. Section 86 vs. Section 51, Which Reorganization Tool Fits Your Situation?
section 85 vs section 86

Section 85 vs. Section 86 vs. Section 51, Which Reorganization Tool Fits Your Situation?

Section 85, 86, and 51 are all tax-deferred reorganization tools under the Income Tax Act, but they apply to entirely different situations. Section 85 transfers property from a taxpayer into a corporation. Section 86 restructures a shareholder’s existing equity within the same corporation. Section 51 allows a taxpayer to exchange shares of a corporation for other shares of the same corporation or to convert debt of the corporation into its shares where the debt carries a conversion right, without a reorganization of capital.

Choosing the wrong provision or assuming one can do what another was designed for derails an otherwise sound plan. This article explains what each provision does, where each one is used in practice, and how to identify which one applies to your situation.

What Section 85 Does to Property in a Corporation

Section 85 of the Income Tax Act allows a taxpayer to transfer eligible property to a Canadian corporation on a tax-deferred basis. The taxpayer receives shares of the corporation (and possibly some non-share consideration, called boot) in exchange. The two parties file a joint election in the T2057 form designating a transfer price called the elected amount.

By setting the elected amount equal to the adjusted cost base of the property (for non-depreciable capital property) or the undepreciated capital cost (for depreciable property), the taxpayer defers any accrued gain until the corporation eventually disposes of the property. The corporation receives the property at the elected amount as its cost base.

Section 85 is the right tool when property is moving from a taxpayer into a corporation. Classic examples include incorporating a sole proprietorship (transferring business assets equipment, goodwill, inventory into a new corporation), rolling a rental property into a holding company, or transferring shares of one corporation into another. For a full list of what qualifies, see What Property Can You Transfer Under Section 85.

A joint election on the T2057 is always required for section 85 to apply. Both the transferor and the corporation must sign it, and it must be filed with CRA by the filing deadline. There is no automatic rollover if the election is not filed, the transfer happens at fair market value and the gain is triggered immediately.

Section 85 Corporation to Corporation

Subsection 85(2) extends the same rollover to corporate-to-corporate transfers. When one corporation transfers eligible property to another, both corporations can jointly elect under 85(2) in the same way. The mechanics are identical to subsection 85(1), with the addition that partnership interests are eligible property under the corporate version (they are not eligible under the individual version).

The corporation-to-corporation rollover is used in butterfly reorganizations, where a holding company’s assets are divided among multiple operating companies or among multiple shareholders’ holding companies. It is also used when reorganizing affiliated corporations, for example, shifting real estate from an operating corporation to a separate real estate holding company within a family group.

What Section 86 Does Restructuring Equity Within the Same Corporation

Section 86 applies when a shareholder exchanges shares of a corporation for new shares of that same corporation, as part of a reorganization of the corporation’s capital. The Income Tax Act does not define a reorganization of capital, but the CRA’s long-standing position is that it should normally require amendments to the corporation’s articles. In practice, this means passing a special resolution and filing articles of amendment under the governing corporate statute, usually to create the new class of shares the shareholder will receive. Unlike section 85, no tax election or CRA filing is required. The provision applies automatically when the conditions are met.

The mechanics under section 86 are as follows. When a shareholder disposes of shares of a class of the corporation’s capital stock and receives new shares of a different class of that same corporation, the shares are deemed to have been disposed of at an amount that avoids triggering a gain, as long as the value of what is received equals the value of what is given up. Any non-share consideration (boot) the shareholder receives is treated as proceeds on the old shares, which triggers a gain to that extent.

The key distinction from section 85 is the direction of the transaction. Section 85 moves property from a taxpayer into a corporation. Section 86 stays entirely within the same corporation, it is a reclassification or exchange of one shareholder’s shares, not a transfer of underlying assets.

Section 86 and the Estate Freeze

The estate freeze is where section 86 is most commonly encountered. In a typical freeze, a business owner who holds common shares of their operating company exchanges those shares for new fixed-value preferred shares under section 86. The preferred shares have a redemption amount equal to the current fair market value of the company. The existing common shares are cancelled.

New common shares are then issued to a family trust or to adult children at a nominal amount. Because the preferred shares have captured all of the existing value, the new common shares start with minimal worth. Any future growth in the company accrues to the new common shares. The business owner has frozen their taxable estate at the current value, and the future growth passes to the next generation or to a family trust outside the estate.

The section 86 exchange is what actually freezes the value. The family trust subscribing for new common shares is a separate step governed by corporate law and trust law, not by section 86. For a practical overview of how this structure works in the context of selling a business to children, see the intergenerational business transfer rules.

One important caution, Section 86(2) applies where the corporation and the shareholder are not dealing at arm’s length and the fair market value of the shares received is less than the fair market value of the shares given up. In that case, the difference is deemed to have been conferred as a benefit on whomever received the new common shares (typically the children or the trust). Getting the preferred share valuation wrong in an estate freeze under-valuing the freeze price can trigger a deemed benefit that the CRA can assess. Independent valuation is important.

What Section 51 Does Exchanging Shares and Converting Debt

Section 51 applies when a taxpayer acquires shares of a corporation in exchange for a “convertible property” of that same corporation. Under subsection 51(1), convertible property is either another share of the corporation held as capital property, or a bond, debenture or note of the corporation, held as capital property, whose terms give the holder the right to make the exchange. The conversion-right requirement applies only to debt. A share-for-share exchange under paragraph 51(1)(a) does not require the old shares to carry a conversion right, so a shareholder can exchange common shares for preferred shares of the same corporation (or the reverse) under section 51, much as they could under section 86.

When a qualifying exchange occurs, section 51 deems it not to be a disposition of the old property, so no gain or loss arises. The new shares take on the adjusted cost base of the old shares or debt given up. No election is required. No CRA form is filed. The provision applies automatically whenever a qualifying exchange occurs.

Several conditions limit section 51. The taxpayer must receive nothing other than the new shares; any cash, promissory note or other non-share consideration takes the exchange outside section 51. Section 51 also does not apply to an exchange to which subsection 85(1) or 85(2) or section 86 applies, so where the exchange happens in the course of a reorganization of capital, section 86 governs instead. For debt, the right to convert must be part of the terms of the bond, debenture or note itself, not arranged later through a separate agreement. Finally, subsection 51(2) can apply where the new shares are worth less than the property given up and the difference benefits a related person, in much the same way as subsection 86(2). Because section 51 does not require a reorganization of capital, it can be used for an exchange into a class of shares the articles already authorize, without filing articles of amendment.

Common Uses for Section 51

Section 51 is used for debt-to-equity conversions where the debt instrument was documented as a convertible debenture or convertible note when it was issued. If a business owner lent money to their corporation under a convertible loan agreement and now wants to convert that loan into shares, Section 51 applies provided the conversion right was in the original document.

Section 51 is also used for share-for-share exchanges within a corporation where no reorganization of capital is needed, for example, exchanging common shares for an existing, already authorized class of preferred shares. It equally covers shares with built-in conversion rights, such as preferred shares that convert into common shares after a specific date or upon a triggering event. In each case, section 51 ensures no gain is triggered on the exchange, provided the shareholder receives only shares.

What section 51 cannot do is convert a shareholder loan that was not originally documented as convertible. A straightforward shareholder loan without conversion rights, later converted to equity by agreement, does not qualify. In that scenario, the conversion may be a forgiveness of debt or a capital contribution, each with different tax consequences.

The Three Provisions Side by Side

Section 85Section 86Section 51
What movesEligible propertyShares of a corporationShares, or convertible debt, of the corporation
To or withinINTO a corporationWITHIN the same corporationWITHIN the same corporation
What the taxpayer receivesShares (plus possible boot) of the corporationNew shares of the same corporation (plus possible boot)Shares of the same corporation
Election or filing required.Yes, the T2057 joint election with the corporationNoNo
Boot allowedYes, triggers gain to that extent.Yes, triggers gain to that extent.No, any non-share consideration takes the exchange outside section 51
Primary use caseIncorporating a business, rolling assets into a corpEstate freeze, share reclassificationShare-for-share exchanges without a reorganization of capital; converting convertible debt

Choosing the Right Provision for Your Situation

The decision tree is straightforward once you know what you are trying to do.

If you are transferring assets or property from yourself into a corporation, whether for incorporation, real estate planning, or a corporate reorganization, Section 85 is the tool. You will need to file a T2057 election and choose an appropriate elected amount. For a worked example of how the numbers flow, see Section 85 Rollover Examples.

If you already own shares in a corporation and want to change what those shares look like, freezing your equity at a fixed value, create a new class of shares, or reclassify your common shares as preferred shares, Section 86 is the tool. No tax election is needed, but you will generally need to file articles of amendment to create the new share class, and the valuation of the preferred shares must be defensible.

If you want to exchange your shares for shares of another class the corporation is already authorized to issue, without a reorganization of capital, or you hold a debenture or note that by its terms converts into shares, section 51 applies automatically as long as you receive nothing but shares. No election is required. For debt, the conversion right must be documented in the instrument itself.

If you are reorganizing a group of corporations and need to move property between them, section 85(2), the corporation-to-corporation version, is what applies, possibly alongside section 86 at the shareholder level.

Using These Provisions Together

Complex reorganizations often use more than one provision in sequence. The most common combination is section 85 and section 86.

In a freeze of a corporation that holds appreciated assets, the asset transfer might happen under section 85 (rolling property from a holding company to a new operating company), while the shareholder-level equity restructuring happens under section 86 (exchanging the holding company’s common shares for preferred shares). Each provision handles its part of the reorganization, and the sequencing of the steps matters for tax purposes.

A butterfly reorganization splitting a corporation’s assets between two separate shareholders or corporate groups typically involves section 85(2) transfers between related corporations alongside section 86 reorganizations of the holding company shares. These are complex transactions that require careful planning to satisfy both the corporate law and the tax requirements.

For business owners thinking about the lifetime capital gains exemption in connection with an eventual sale, understanding which provision governs which step of the structure is essential. The LCGE is only available on qualifying shares and the share structure that comes out of a reorganization using sections 85, 86, and 51 determines which shares are qualifying shares and in whose hands.

Work With a Tax Lawyer Before You Reorganize

The Income Tax Act is precise about which provision applies in which situation. Using section 86 where section 85 was required, means no election was filed and the transfer happened at fair market value. Using section 85 where section 86 applies means an election was filed for a transaction that was really a share exchange, which raises its own issues. Getting the sequencing wrong in a multi-step reorganization can trigger gains, deemed dividends, or a GAAR challenge.

Kalfa Law Firm structures corporate reorganizations for business owners and investors across Canada, including incorporations, estate freezes, and multi-corporation restructurings. If you are considering a reorganization and are not sure which provision applies, the conversation should happen before you act. Book a consultation.

FAQs:

Shira Kalfa, BA, JD, Partner and Founder
Shira Kalfa is the founding partner of Kalfa Law Firm. Shira’s practice is focused in corporate-commercial and private M&A law including corporate reorganizations, corporate restructuring, mergers and acquisitions, commercial financing, secured lending and transactional law.

© Kalfa Law Firm | November 22, 2026
The above provides information of a general nature only. This does not constitute legal or accounting advice. All transactions or circumstances vary, and specified legal advice is required to meet your particular needs. If you have a legal question you should consult with a lawyer.

Consult with a business lawyer today. Schedule your free consultation

    Send us a message, but doing so does not mean that we are your lawyers until we have confirmed so in writing. Please do not include any confidential information in your message.

    Close Menu

    Book an Appointment 1-800-631-7923

    Call Us
    1-800-631-7923
    Speak with a Lawyer
    1-800-631-7923

    Email Us
    [email protected]